Race, Cancer and Inequality
19th November 2019
Overall, people from minority ethnic groups are less likely to get cancer than white people. However, there are exceptions. Black men are approximately twice as likely to get prostate cancer than white men in England. Black and Asian females, aged 65 years and over, are at a higher risk of cervical cancer compared to white females in England.
A 2018 report by the Race Equality Foundation concluded the following key messages regarding race, cancer and inequality:
In 2015, the National Cancer Intelligence Network (NCIN) found that people from BAME communities have higher rates of myeloma and stomach cancer. They also reported males from the BAME group have higher rates of prostate cancer. Furthermore, liver cancer is highest among people from Asian ethnic groups compared with the white ethnic group, as are mouth cancer in females and cervical cancer in the over 65s.
There are some clear connections between behaviours and the prevalence of certain cancers. For example, the chewing of areca nut and chewing tobacco is associated with increased risk of developing oesophageal squamous cell carcinoma and has been found to be more common practice in Bangladeshi women than it is for individuals from other ethnic groups.
Moreover, a 2014 study found that the British White population were more likely to attend breast cancer screening than the BAME population. Big differences in attendance were found in South East and North London where Bangladeshi women had low levels of uptake compared to White British and other groups.
In recent years, the identification of ethnicity within Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) data has improved, with a newly developed system of linking cancer registrations with other information such as admitted care and outpatient attendance. However, issues regarding the completeness of ethnicity in HES data remains. For example, a 2013 study found there is a miscoding of up to 35% of ethnicity data of all patients who self-report. Furthermore, for cancer registrations for some NHS trusts, six were identified as having less than half of the ethnic data for their patients.
Patients from BAME backgrounds are less likely to respond to the Cancer Experience Survey than those from a white background. Of those that did respond to the 2010 survey, more rated their cancer experience critically than those from a white background.
It has been argued that diversity needs to be embedded into the design and provision of cancer services.
Delays in entering the cancer care system result in a delayed diagnosis and consequently delayed treatment. A common reason for delay in a patient seeking help is being unable to recognise symptoms as possible cancer. People who are unable to recognise the early symptoms of cancer are more likely to wait longer than 2 weeks before visiting their GP. People from BAME groups, as well as older people, men and the less educated, have been found to be less likely to recognise cancer warning signs such as a persistent cough.
Another factor is a delay in referral, the majority of which are made to secondary care by GPs. The Cancer Patient Experience Surveys have shown that patients from BAME backgrounds are more likely than white patients to have a delayed referral to secondary care.
A crucial starting point to ensure that cancer care for BAME populations is given special attention within the NHS is in developing policies that address issues affecting this population.
Patient advocates have been found to improve patient experience of cancer care. The quality of advocates matter to the impact they have on patient experience and those with good interpersonal skills, well matched with the patients’, can improve knowledge and understanding of the illness.
A further factor to consider is the lack of consensus of who is part of an ethnic group. Ethnic categorisations have undergone several modifications due to the changing nature of ethnic identification, apart from the category defined as “white” which is seen as the ethnic majority and assumed to be white, of British origin and English speaking. Yet, because of this approach, other “white” groups, such as the Irish, are not classified as a distinct group, leading to their invisibility in the data. Much smaller groups of people are also often missed out.
The role of the GP – Race, Cancer and Inequality
It is important that GPs are aware of the inequalities which still exist surrounding race and cancer. As often the first point of contact for cancer patients, GPs play a vital role in the reduction of these inequalities; particularly surrounding reducing delays in referral to secondary care for treatment, and increasing awareness together with health education regarding cancer symptoms and available support services for BAME communities. The C the Signs tool can support GPs in all these areas; supporting GPs to refer all patients with the early signs and symptoms of cancer, regardless of ethnic background, as well as signpost GPs to available support services and patient information for BAME communities.
National Cancer Intelligence Network (2015). Cancer and Equality groups: Key Metrics 2015 report. Public Health England. PHE Publications gateway number 2015210
Jack, RH., Moller, H., Ronson, T., Davies, E. (2014) Breast cancer screening uptake among women from different ethnic groups in London: a population-based cohort study BMJ Open
Saunder, C.L., Abel, G. A., El Turabi, A., Lyratzopoulos, G. (2013) Accuracy of routinely recorded ethnic group information compared with self reported ethnicity: evidence form the English Cancer Patients Experience Survey. BMJ Open
Saunders, C.L., Abel, G.A., Lyratzopoulos, G.(2015) Inequalities in reported cancer patient experience by socio-demographic characteristic and cancer site: evidence from respondents to the English Cancer Patient Experience Survey. European Journal of Cancer Care, 24, 85-98
Abel, G.A., Saunder, C.L., Lyratzopoulos, G. (2016) Post-sampling mortality and non-response patterns in the English Cancer Patient Survey: Implications for epidiemiological studies based on surveys of cancer patients. Cancer Epidemiology 41: 34-41.
Johnson M.R.D (2013) Diversity in cancer care – the importance of transcultural nursing. European Cancer Congress, Amsterdam. The Netherlands
Smith et al 2005) Patients help seeking experiences and delay in cacner presentation a qualitative synthesis. Lancet, 366 (9488) 825-831.).
Quaife, S.L., Forbes, L.J., Ramirez, A.J., Brain, K.E. Donnelly, C., Simon, A.E., Wardle, J (2014) Recognistion of cancer warning signs and anticipated delay in help-seeking in a population sample of adults in the UK. British Journal of Cancer, 110, 12-18
Lyratzopoulos G, Neal, R.D., Barbiere, J, M, Rubin, G.P., Abel, G.A (2012) Variation in number of general practitioner consultations before hospital referral for cancer: findings from the 2010 National Cancer Patient Experience Survey in England. Lancet Oncology, 13: 353-65
Fazil, Q., Aujla, N., Hale, C., Kai, J. (2015) Unequal treatment: health care experiences and needs of patients with cancer from minority ethnic communities. Diversity in Health and Care, 12(3): 95-103.